Animal crush videos still a thing

The things you learn from random “Next Door” emails.

A South Florida man pleaded guilty and was sentenced to 60 months for creating and administering “online chat groups dedicated to the distribution and discussion of sexual and violent videos depicting monkeys being mutilated and burned.”

I confess to not knowing what had become of federal regulation of “animal crush” videos after United States v. Stevens declared the federal ban invalid. Congress amended the law in 2010 to add a requirement that the video be “obscene” (incorporating by reference the Miller definition). The Fifth Circuit in 2014 rejected a constitutional challenge to the amended law. The obscenity element pushes the speech into a recognized category of unprotected speech. And rather than raising an R.A.V. problem by targeting one narrow content-based form of otherwise-unprotected speech, the law targets secondary effects by drying up the market for the conduct of harming animals.

Congress amended § 48 in 2019 to add a prohibition on crushing animals in addition to existing prohibitions on making and distributing crush videos.1

  1. For the “All Hail Trump” Files: The DOJ statement on the guilty plea highlights President Trump’s role in signing the 2019 amendment. Besides being irrelevant, it is kind of misleading. This defendant pleaded guilty to charges under pre-existing distribution provisions, signed into law by (gasp!!) Barack Hussein Obama. ↩︎