The Eleventh Circuit heard argument this week in Damsky v. Summerlin, a First Amendment suit by a University of Florida law student suspended for making racist and antisemitic social media posts. The district court issued an injunction ordering his reinstatement; a divided motions panel stayed the injunction pending appeal.
Based on the argument (before Adalberto Jordan, Jill Pryor, and Nancy Abudu),UF will go down and go down hard. Jordan suggested that Gavin Kevin1 Newsom got it right in his dissent from the stay. And he questioned whether to accept that Tinker applies to colleges (Newsom made this point in his dissent). On their own terms, UF’s arguments (and the judge’s questions pushing against Damsky’s attorney) demonstrate that the university can win only if vast swaths of obnoxious-but-protected political speech become off-limits for college students.
I am watching Damsky in part because FIU is fighting a similar free speech battle after suspending three students (including one law student) over statements in a racist chat group. The FIU case went to a bench trial a few weeks ago and post-trial briefing is due early next month. News reports describe a focus (and the judge’s interest in) questions of disruption and whether the posts disrupted university activities (i.e., Tinker). If Damsky comes out the way the panel seems headed and for the reasons hinted at, that potential direction of the FIU trial will prove erroneous. I am curious to see if these parties and the court listened to the Damsky argument and address the new direction in which these legal issues are (and should be) going.
- I keep making this mistake. ↩︎
