About that “paradigm-shattering” Charter of the Board of Peace:
- Someone somewhere toiled away to supply the phrase “Judgment guided and justice honored.” As writing goes, it is certainly, I guess, writing.
- It is true that Donald Trump is the president of the United States. But the charter mostly treats him not as acting ex officio but as, well, Donald J. Trump: “Donald J. Trump shall serve as inaugural Chairman of the Board of Peace, and he shall separately serve as inaugural representative of the United States of America, subject only to the provisions of Chapter III.” Does the United States, as first mover, have the “exclusive authority to create, modify, or dissolve subsidiary entities as necessary or appropriate to fulfill the Board of Peace’s mission?” No. “The Chairman” does. Who’s the chairman? Why, Donald J. Trump, of course.
- Say, is there any kind of sane mechanism for resolving interpretive disputes? Not exactly: “[T]he Chairman is the final authority regarding the meaning, interpretation, and application of this Charter.” Who’s that again? Glad you asked. The chairman is Donald J. Trump. Sing it out like you’re Robert Preston in The Music Man.
- Is this a successor to or replacement of the United Nations? Well, maybe. Or maybe not. It will continue in existence until its chairman–I believe the fellow’s name is Donald J. Trump–gets bored or angry or is foisted off with a Nobel Peace Prize like a baby with a pacifier: “The Board of Peace shall dissolve at such time as the Chairman considers necessary or appropriate.”
- Okay, but the articles of the charter address the important issues, right? Yes! “The Board of Peace will have an official seal, which shall be approved by the Chairman.” That chairman–I believe his name is Donald J. Trump–might want to consult this for guidance. Or possibly this.
- Does the charter say what happens with that billion dollars? Alas, no. One assumes they were getting around to that part, but ended up burning up a lot of time on the thing with the seal and arguing over what the hell “judgment guided and justice honored” means. I guess these kinds of things happen when you’re shattering paradigms.
- Do the member states get a say in the kinds of sub-entities that the board can create? I mean, if you’re going to replace the UN, you might start by making sure that you avoid the corruption that has infested some of its subsidiary bodies–especially if you’re forking over a billion dollars in this unnecessarily unstable global economy. Well, I have some bad news: “The Chairman shall have exclusive authority to create, modify, or dissolve subsidiary entities as necessary or appropriate to fulfill the Board of Peace’s mission.” (That chairman is Donald J….well, you know.) That’s sort of like letting the fox “create, modify, or dissolve” the henhouse.
- A billion dollars is a lot of money. Do the states that make up the executive board get much say in what the entity will do? Not exactly. “The Executive Board shall be selected by the Chairman and consist of leaders of global stature.” “Leaders of global stature” is, I must say, a lovely way to describe a mountain-sized opportunity for abused discretion. Much clearer than “judgment guided and justice honored.” Members of the executive board are “subject to removal by the Chairman and renewable at his discretion.” That board starts with the inaugural chairman–I believe you know his name–and, assuming the U.S. is on it, that gives him two votes to start with. The board also gives a voting role to a “Chief Executive,” whose qualifications are not noted but who will be “nominated by the Chairman” and subject to a majority vote of the board. I’m picturing a chief executive of truly global stature–a Steve Witkoff or Dana White, say, or maybe a Barron Trump. In any event, that’s basically three votes on the board for one Donald J. Trump. “Decisions of the Executive Board shall be made by a majority of its members present and voting, including the Chief Executive. Such decisions shall go into effect immediately.” Fear not, however. Lest that pesky majority rule prove irksome or inconvenient, those decisions are “subject to veto by the Chairman at any time thereafter.”
- What about the next chairman? The U.S. started this thing. Keeping leadership permanently with the U.S. is maybe not great from an institution-building perspective, but one can understand it. So is the next chairman the next president of the United States? Well, not necessarily: “The Chairman shall at all times designate a successor for the role of Chairman.” No ex officio role for the United States here. The next president might want to stay in the good graces of one Donald J. Trump, Inaugural Chairman, Board of Peace. After all, he could always call on his good friend and mentor Vladimir Putin to succeed him.
- One of the more significant provisions is this one: “The Board of Peace shall ensure the provision of such privileges and immunities as are necessary for the exercise of the functions of the Board of Peace and its subsidiary entities and personnel.” If you’re going to threaten most of Europe and destabilize most of the global economy, and if you think all law is power and all power should be exercised to punish one’s enemies and all of one’s enemies are subject to arrest wherever they are and regardless of their official or diplomatic status, naturally you are going to look ahead to the eventuality of your own indictment by various national and international bodies. Best to fend off those concerns in advance. Those international hotels aren’t going to visit themselves, you know.
- Is there a sane response for any state that is “invited” to pony up for this magnificent body? Yes: “Can we just pay the billion dollar bribe and skip the rest of it? It seems like a lot of unnecessary paperwork to go through just to pay you off. Can’t we just give you a bag of cash, like that Tom Homan fellow?”
- Is it possible to simply pass these articles along credulously, without intelligent comment, without noting its lacunae and absurdities, without noting the extent to which it is not so much an international body as a kind of private golf club with guns, owned and operated by one Donald J. Trump? I don’t see how it could be.
