President Trump pardoned Pete Rose (posthumously) for his 1990 tax-evasion conviction.1 Prawfs contributors bring you all sides of that event: Gerard considers how that squares with the history of the pardon power, while I consider (literally) what it has to do with baseball, because the pardon is apparently intended to get the Hall of Fame to induct Rose.
In fact, it should not make a difference to Rose’ Hall eligibility and should not affect his selection. I do not know how or why Trump (who, granted, is an idiot trying to make himself the story) or anyone around him expects that it would.
MLB took its necessary step to Rose getting into the Hall last spring in removing all deceased players and personnel (including Rose and Shoeless Joe Jackson) from the permanently ineligible list. That makes Rose Hall-eligible under the Hall’s internal rules (MLB has nothing to say about Hall selection), allowing him to be selected and inducted if the voters approve him. The Classic Baseball Era (pre-1980) Committee can consider Rose at its next meeting in late 2027.
The pardon adds nothing to the mix. MLB placed Rose on the ineligible list2 because Rose bet on MLB games (including, it has become clear over the years, games involving his team). It did not ban him because he failed to pay taxes on his gambling winnings. The pardon cannot exonerate him of his offense against baseball; MLB’s decision to remove deceased players from the list did that. The committee members now must decide whether that offense reflects sufficiently bad character to decline to support his induction or whether Rose’s baseball achievements outweigh that bad character. The presidential pardon should not change committee members’ calculus–no serious voter should say “I was not going to vote for Rose because of his gambling, but now that he has been pardoned for tax evasion, I will vote for him, even though he bet on baseball and his team.” That voter always was wiling to overlook the gambling and vote for him, with or without the pardon. Fair enough. Own that.
