Old-School Grand Juries

Here is what I meant by yesterday’s post. A standard grand jury in 1791 or 1868 was run by a judge. The judge would instruct the grand jurors on the law about the specific allegations that they were asked to assess. These instructions were public and could be cited as authority. One of these was used in the 14/3 cases on the definition of insurrection.

This structure strikes me as better for the average case. Law gets generated, which does not happen today. Judges can instruct grand jurors in an impartial manner, which is not what at least some prosecutors do now. Now does this mean that the current practice is unlawful? I’m unsure. Some procedural details can rise to the level of a constitutional entitlement, but most don’t. A jury trial doesn’t work exactly as it did in 1791 or 1868 either, though the differences are less dramatic. Anyway, food for thought.