Erie and affidavit of merit statutes

SCOTUS holds that a state Med Mal affidavit-of-merit statute does not apply in federal court. Justice Barrett writes for eight for the majority that FRCP 8(a) is a controlling-and-valid federal rule. Justice Jackson concurs in the judgment to identify FRCP 3 and 12 as controlling-and-valid federal rules.

This is the cleanest Erie case in awhile. Everyone agrees on the basic framework, including that federal rules are supposed to be given their plain meaning and not (as Justice Ginsburg argued and as Justice Jackson attempts to preserve in a footnote) narrowly construed with sensitivity to important state interests and regulatory policies. They depart on the controlling federal rule, based on disagreeing as to when the AoM kicks in (pre- or post-filing). On first read, I think Jackson has the better read: The AoM statute does not add to the pleading requirements; it adds to the requirements for filing (conflicting with FRCP 3) and the bases for dismissal (conflicting with FRCP 12(b)(6) and 12(d)).

Both approaches answer ongoing Erie disputes in favor of federal law. For example, anti-SLAPP motions cannot provide a basis for resolving a case outside of FRCP 12(b)(6), 12(c), or 56. There is no room for “gap-filling” state procedure in the interstices of the Federal Rules, even when serving substantive purposes.

I have to spend some time considering how it affects the Erie topic I want to write about–standards for anonymous litigation, where the controlling federal rules are not textually clear and the legal standard comes from judicial interpretation. This case cannot address when a court interprets a rule and when it creates procedural common law.