Grand Jury Originalism

One subject that is ripe for revision is grand jury law. The way grand juries operate now is sharply at odds with how they worked in 1791. To take one example, federal judges used to give public instructions to grand jurors before they made charging decisions that spoke to the specific allegations and legal issues. A pretty good original public meaning argument can be made that the current practice of giving only general instructions and leaving the details to prosecutors (which does not seem to be dictated by any rule) is both unlawful and less protective of individual liberty. I might start playing with this idea, though I’m no criminal procedure expert.