The Principles of the Trumpy International Law “Paradigm” Begin to Coalesce

Let us pretend for a second that the “Board of Peace” is a) a serious endeavor that b) is taken seriously by anyone whose salary doesn’t depend on doing so, b1) is taken seriously by those whose salary does depend on it even when they’re speaking privately, and c) represents some kind of new “paradigm” of international law, where “law” is defined roughly as “law.” It’s not, they don’t, and it doesn’t. But any world in which the executive branch can mark the anniversary of a massive crime by engaging in full-tilt Orwellianism, and draw nary a peep from people who have spent years invoking Orwell or casting their gaze up from their brandy snifter and solemnly intoning the phrase “live not by lies,” is a world that knows a thing or two about pretense. Surely we can manage this one.

What is the first–quite possibly the only–principle of this bold new paradigm? The answer is: Do not upstage or offend Donald J. Trump.

That’s it. It’s perfectly clear. It shouldn’t be mistaken for “don’t offend the president of the United States” or “don’t offend the United States.” It is neither of those things. Like the chairmanship of the “Board of Peace” itself, it’s not about the president or the presidency and has nothing at all to do with the “king’s two bodies.” Donald J. Trump does not particularly care about the country or its leadership as a continuing political enterprise. He’s not one for political theory. He thinks someone with a grade-school level of civics education is just another one of them fancy egghead types. And he would clap and caper like a five-year-old boy if another nation offended or humiliated an American president, if he happened to dislike that president. (For that matter, I’m sure he would be delighted if a president he does like got upstaged, as long as the president in question is not himself. Can anyone doubt that if Trump is still alive three years from now and a president Vance or Rubio makes a poor showing at Davos, he’ll be thrilled?)

He does care when another nation’s leader, through such underhanded tactics as speaking eloquently and sensibly, gets a standing O and he doesn’t. For Trump, that’s practically a casus belli. I should note that I’m using the word “practically” out of an abundance of caution. It is well within the realm of plausibility that Trump thinks that offending him, Donald J. Trump, personally is a legal justification for the use of military force, with or without the blessing of Congress.*

As keystones for a new “paradigm” of international law go, this one seems…not great. I suppose it can claim a kind of “symmetry.” Even a stable democratic ally of the United States, like Canada, which has a long friendship with this country and can claim 160 deaths of military personnel–none of whom, one assumes, suffered from “bone spurs”–aiding the U.S. in recent hostilities in Afghanistan and Iraq, can fall afoul of this rule. And even a rogues’ gallery of tyrants and human rights abusers can be staunch friends and allies, provided they pony up, suck up, and shut up. It still strikes me, though, that it may be unwise to build a “paradigm” of international law, not around even the United States or whoever occupies its presidency at any given time, but around the erratic temper of one specific 79-year-old man of dubious mental and physical health.

*I trust that those former Canadians who not only defended the State Department, but positively cheered it on, when it said it was going to aggressively use its (delegated) visa and naturalization powers against individuals with views “detrimental to the interests of the United States” will be equally supportive when the regime gets around to wielding that discretion against naturalized Canadian lawyers and think-tankers and not just Palestinian grad students. And, honestly, as a matter of consistency and principle it should be used that way. I have no doubt that the vast majority of naturalized Canadians in the United States actively oppose “the interests of the United States” with respect to the presidential tariffs and its treatment of Canada in general, and a good many of them have said so. By this regime’s lights, Canada is an enemy of the United States, and Canadians who are here on visas or have become naturalized citizens are suspect.